@Ireth, two things I noticed that seem to be wrong with your rolls. It looks like you're adding level. When I said the to hit bonus is +1 at level 2, I meant you add the to hit bonus instead of the level, not in addition to.
The other mistake is that you're logging in as "Ireth." If you log into Rolz as "Baldhart," you tend to roll within 2 points of the maximum roll. I think Rolz is in love with "Baldhart," and is trying to win her over with frequent and well-timed high rolls. It's working. She's not seeing the Unseen Servant anymore, and stopped returning his phone calls.
@Steerpike, I think you should log in as "Mauve" and type "# Shield Spell" whenever you roll for bad guys.
The other mistake is that you're logging in as "Ireth." If you log into Rolz as "Baldhart," you tend to roll within 2 points of the maximum roll. I think Rolz is in love with "Baldhart," and is trying to win her over with frequent and well-timed high rolls. It's working. She's not seeing the Unseen Servant anymore, and stopped returning his phone calls.
@Steerpike, I think you should log in as "Mauve" and type "# Shield Spell" whenever you roll for bad guys.
Mythic Scribe
Valar Lord